Dr. Lindsey's Multiple Sclerosis Website

Tysabri update 1/28/10

Home
Ampyra
Tysabri update 1/28/10
Recent and current research
ECTRIMS Sept 2009
AAN April 2009
World Congress in Montreal, 2008
AAN April 2008
New diagnosis of MS
Multiple Sclerosis Basic Information
Current Treatments
Interferon versus Glatiramer--update 11/07
Talk on stem cells--2/13/08
ECTRIMS 2007
Talk on new treatments--August 23, 2007
About Dr. Lindsey
Research Interests
Map/Directions
Links
Clinic information
Contact Us

New cases of PML reported

1/28/10  There are now 31 confirmed cases of PML since the reintroduction of Tysabri.  Eleven of these cases were reported in September and October and 7 in November and December.  Biogen is currently issuing updates monthly, and this information is from their update issued 1/12/10. 
Of the 31 cases, 19 were in Europe and 10 in the US.  The risk of PML is higher in people treated previously with immunosuppressive drugs like mitoxantrone, cyclophosphamide, or methotrexate.  The higher risk in Europe may be related to more use of immunosuppressive drugs there than in the US. 
The risk for PML varies with duration of treatment.  The number of cases per 1000 patients is 0.44 for people treated 13-24 months, 1.53 for 25-36 months, and 0.30 for 37-48 months.  There has been only one case reported in the first year of treatment.  The rate for people treated 37-48 months is not certain since there are not that many people in this group yet. 
I will continue to closely follow the monthly reports.  At present, the risk is not much different than the 1 per 1000 estimate we had when Tysabri was reintroduced.  One concern is that the risk would continue to increase with time on treatment, so the number of cases in the 37-48 month group will be of interest.   
The outcome in the 31 cases has been varied.  About a third are reported to have done well, but I am not sure what that means.  Eight cases were fatal.  PML is a serious disease, even with quick recognition and change in treatment. 

Web links:
At present, I don't have a reliable link for current information on the number of PML cases.  I get information through the local Biogen medical affairs representative.  As far as I know, they are not maintaining a website with information for patients. 
Biogen reports Tysabri complications to the SEC because it is information that might affect the stock price, and to the FDA for safety reasons.  As I understand it, they do not plan to communicate to physicians or the public in general unless there is new information that would change our opinion of the level of risk from Tysabri.  Links to the SEC reports can be found online at http://www.biogenidec.com/site/tysabri-information-center.html.  They are titled "Form 8-K regarding other events".  Form 8-K includes investor information besides new cases of PML, so you have to sort through some other things.  Another source is http://www.biogenidec.com/tpme.  This page was updated every Friday with the last update on July 24, 2009.  I don't think they are planning to issue any new updates, so it may get more difficult to get current information on the number of PML cases.  I found information on the two most recent cases on the FDA website http://www.fda.gov/Drugs/DrugSafety/PostmarketDrugSafetyInformationforPatientsandProviders/ucm107198.htm
Updates:
10/16/09  A patient treated with Tysabri for 21 months developed lymphoma in the brain.  There was no sign of the Epstein-Barr virus infection which causes some cases of lymphoma.  This is a serious disease, but this is the first case reported in association with Tysabri. 
9/22/09  Two additional cases have been reported.  There weren't any details about how long the 2 new cases had been on treatment.  There was one additional case in Europe and one in the US. 
8/20/09  There have now been a total of 11 cases of PML since reintroduction of Tysabri.  Three new cases were reported in June and one in July.  All cases have been in MS patients, and 8 of the 11 are in Europe with 3 in the US. 
There are currently 30,600 patients on treatment for 12 months or more, 18,400 on treatment for 18 months, and 10,000 on treatment for 2 years. 
The timeline is as follows:
Date reported      Months on treatment
7/30/08                   17
7/31/08                   14
10/29/08                 14
12/10/08                 26
2/5/09                    12
4/15/09                   31
5/18/09                   24
6/10/09                   35
6/19/09                   34
6/23/09                   30
7/24/09                   29
One obvious concern is that the risk of PML may go up with longer treatment.  If this is true, then there should be an increasing number of cases over time, although it is reassuring that only one addition case occurred in July.  I will continue to monitor this situation very closely.  At present I have about 15 patients on Tysabri, and all of them have pretty severe MS which makes the risk more acceptable. 
2/10/09  An additional case of PML from Europe, occurring after 12 months of treatment, was reported 2/5/09.  This brings the total number of confirmed cases to 5, with about 20,200 patients on Tysabri for over a year. 
1/6/09 An additional case of PML from Europe was reported on 12/11/08.  The patient had received 26 months of Tysabri,and the diagnosis of PML was confirmed by PCR and MRI.  He presented with cognitive changes.  He had previously failed treatment with interferon and was responding well to Tysabri.  His last dose was on 10/29.  He was treated with immunoadsorption.  His current status is not reported. 
10/30/08  An additional case of PML was reported on 10/29/08.   This patient had MS since 2001, and had been on Tysabri for 14 months.  Following her last dose in late September she had some worsening of her previous MS symptoms, and then developed troubles with language in late October.  Brain MRI was suggestive of PML, and JC virus DNA was detected in the spinal fluid.  The patient was treated with plasma exchange, and is back at home.  She was not receiving any other immunosuppressive medicines while on Tysabri, but she has been treated with methotrexate in the past (not for MS).
There are currently 18,000 patients that have been on Tysabri more than 12 months and 9500 that have been on treatment more than 18 months.  
The two previous cases of PML, both in Germany, (see report below), have improved, but they continue to have deficits related to the PML.  
We will continue to monitor the number of PML cases.  For now, the number of cases is small compared to the number of people on treatment.  The risk of PML seems to be acceptable for people with severe MS, and I am continuing to recommend Tysabri to carefully selected patients.  If you have any concerns, please call the office.  

J. William Lindsey, MD
University of Texas Multiple Sclerosis Research Group
Houston, Texas

copyright 2007-2010 John William Lindsey